Friday, October 3, 2008

How I Traded Today

What a wacky market this is. We get the decision that everybody wants and has been anxiously waiting for and thing go down the toilet fast. I made two trades today. Fortunately I managed my trades adequately even though I had dubious reasons for taking them.

I bought FDX on a channel breakout after the opening gap. I really didn't have a high probability setup, but I thought that FDX would mimic the general market and head up more. It was up 2R until the announcement was made and then it fell like just about every other stock in the market. I protected some of the gains and made off with 1.2R for the day.

Short Sellers are Heros

I got this in my e-mail from Investment U yesterday:

Short Sellers and Speculators Are Heroes,
Not Villains

by Dr. Mark Skousen, Advisory Panelist


Dear Investment U Reader,

I'm expecting a lot of nasty e-mails on this column, but the truth needs to be told. Short-term traders, especially short sellers, are often blamed erroneously for manipulating stock prices, forcing them down far below their real value, and for creating crashes and general chaos on Wall Street.

In fact, short sellers have been identified as so vile by SEC Chairman Christopher Cox that he has banned short selling for some 980 publicly traded companies. Chairman Cox and other critics of the market blame short sellers for several grievances:

1. Short sellers destabilize prices in a shaky market, and in a panic can make matters worse, causing a crash.

2. Short sellers artificially engage in "bear raids," where traders gang up on an illiquid - or thinly held - publicly traded company and push the price way down below their intrinsic value. After the stock plunges, traders cover their shorts and buy up good companies at bargain prices.

By temporarily banning short sales, Chairman Cox hopes to prevent the stock market from declining further. (So far he has been unsuccessful.)

So who's right, the short-selling proponents, or Chairman Cox? The best way to determine the truth is to look at what short selling is, and the evidence on what it does.

What Exactly is Short Selling?

Short selling is a way for investors and speculators to bet on falling prices, and for long-term investors to protect their investment portfolio during a bear market.


Most investors profit from stocks by buying a stock and then selling it when the price goes up. Short sellers do the opposite. They sell a stock first and then buy it back when the price goes down.

They accomplish this by borrowing the stock first and then selling it. To close their trade they purchase the shares, hopefully at a discount. When they buy the stock back, they return the borrowed stock to the owner and pocket the profit from the difference in price. Short sales must take place in a "margin account" because the sellers are using borrowed money.

"Naked" short selling is more controversial. It's defined as a short sale by brokers/dealers who sell a stock short without borrowing it first. The SEC recently banned this practice as well.

Investors can also sell short a stock that they own. This is the least controversial technique. It's often used at the end of the calendar year to lock in profits in a stock that has gone up in price.

But with the potential positive and negative aspects of short selling, what do the facts from the scientific community show?

Adam Reed, a finance professor at University of North Carolina, and Arturo Bris, a finance professor at Yale, have done extensive studies on short selling. He has come to the following conclusions.

On bear raids:

  • "In recent years, when academic researchers have looked for bear raids - even in those areas in which investors suspected that they existed - they haven't found them." They couldn't even find evidence of bear raids on 19 beleaguered financial stocks. They conclude that short sellers reacted to downward momentum, rather than caused it. "Typically, short sellers trade in response to past negative news," Professor Bris said, "rather than inducing current stock price drops."
Note: While bear raids are unlikely in mid to large companies because of their size, I do think that short sellers can artificially manipulate small-cap and penny stocks. I've seen it too many times!

On short selling causing greater volatility:
  • Professor Reed found just the opposite, that "stocks without short selling not infrequently trade at prices that deviate widely from their true value."
Three Little-Known Benefits of Short Selling

Academic studies also show three major advantages of using short selling:

  • First, they counter the "irrational exuberance" that company officials and bullish promoters parade about their stocks, and encourage a more sensible valuation of a company's worth.

  • Second, short selling is a legitimate way to hedge your position. It is not simply a strategy to profit from falling prices. Major institutions and conservative investors often use short selling to lock in a position for a period of time, and protect themselves from downside risk.

  • Third, short sellers and short-term traders provide extra liquidity and thus reduce bid-asked spreads. It is short-term speculators that allow long-term investors to sell when they want to.
From a practical point of view, while short selling of individual stocks is temporarily prohibited, investors can still play the down side of the market by buying short exchange-traded funds (ETFs), such as SHORT S&P500 PROSHARES (AMEX: SH).

Professor Bris concludes with this word of caution: "The ban on short selling may prolong the crisis in the sense that it will now take the markets longer to adjust to the true values of financial companies."

Short sellers and speculators are in fact helping us make the markets more efficient and more profitable for investors. In today's market environment we can use as many of these heroes as we can get.

Let's hope Chairman Cox comes to his senses and reverses his ban on short selling soon.

Good trading, AEIOU,

Mark

Thursday, October 2, 2008

Should have done better



I had a .57R day on one trade. I could have done much better if I had avoided over-thinking a few stocks on my watchlist. I had too much of "it can't go any lower" mentality today and it cost me. Here are 3 trades I was considering taking. All were down over 5% and I thought that it would be expecting too much for them to go lower than that. I was wrong.

The stock I did trade had no real setup whatsoever. My thought was that as the market rolled over, NOC would follow suit and end up at the lows of the day. I'm not sure what convinced me of this. I was up 2R at one point, but gave back most of it by the day's end. Not very smart.

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

Month In Review September 2008

Total R for the month 14.08
Win percentage 40.68%
Total trades 59
# of days I traded 14
Average # of trades per day 4.21
Average "R" per trading day 1.01
Expectancy for the month .30

All in all a pretty decent month. I'd like to bump up the number of trades to 100, but it is difficult when I trade only part of the time.

As I've said before, I'll need about 5R each month to be able to be financially free, so I'm happy with this month's results.

One that worked and one that didn't

This first example is a trade that worked for me today. Unfortunately, I let my fear and emotions get the best of me and risked less than half a percent of my portfolio on this trade. The stock was liquid enough, but my plan of buying more than 4,000 shares caused my heart to flutter when I saw how much it would cost--nearly $200,000.

I've never put that much into one stock so I decided to go with a much lower number. The market is still pretty fragile, so I am hesitant to go full bore right now. I could have made a bundle, but I guess it's better to feel somewhat safe going into a trade.

I shorted PCLN after the "bear flag" broke out at noon. Things looked good as the stock dropped to $64. But then the whole market turned and started heading higher and PCLN went along with it. I feel OK about this trade. I lose on more trades than I win, so this one wasn't a big deal. The only thing that bothers me is that I lost more than 1R. I must have calculated my stop loss wrong or something.

All in all, this was a good day to trade. There was enough action in the market, and we didn't see huge gaps that made things difficult to trade. For the day I made 5.48R.

Tuesday, September 30, 2008

Another day of nothing

This market is just goofy. I didn't take any trades today. I saw a few candidates, but I thought the market would gap and consolidate for the whole day. I didn't expect things to move up as much as they did. Shows you what I know.

Today's action makes tomorrow's even harder to predict.

I'm happy to sit on a 14R gain for the month and make a new start in October.

Monday, September 29, 2008

A good day to be away

Yowza!! That was one ugly day. I had no idea that the bill wouldn't pass. I thought it was a done deal.

This could actually be a good thing. It's a much more natural way for the markets to get back to equilibrium. It will be a shocker for a while, but eventually things will come back around. They always do. If you go back and look at the tremendous hits the market took in 1987, 1998, 2001, 2002, they look like mere blips on the screen. Someday this will be a blip as well.

But today people feel that the end is near. That can be good for the markets too. We've gotten way too cocky since 2003 and arrogance creates the problems that we are seeing in the market today.

My dad called me today worried that I was getting my buttocks kicked and destroying my financial future. I assured him that all my money was currently out of the market and that I was doing just fine. He asked me if this was the end of the stock market as we know it. I asked him if he remembered the crash in 1987. He said, "You know, I really don't. It must not have affected me that much, because I don't remember it at all."

As devastating as that crash was in 1987 (a loss of 40% on the DOW--20% of that in ONE DAY), when you look at the chart you can see that things recovered to where they were before the crash in just two year's time. The markets have a remarkable ability to heal themselves and even though everybody is saying "This time is different!", I really think that this will end up being an amazing opportunity to buy some really beaten up stocks on the cheap.

So even though the headlines are screaming "BIGGEST ONE DAY LOSS IN HISTORY", they are referring to dollars lost--not percentage lost. If we were to duplicate that October day in 1987 the DOW would have had to lose over 2200 points today.

Sunday, September 28, 2008

Get ready for week that will make history

If this deal falls apart--watch out!

I'll be happily watching from the sidelines. I've considered taking my 14R gain for September and sitting on it until things are more clear. Things are far too messy right now to try and be too fancy.

Things at my job have become more complicated as well, so I just might have to sit this whole thing out anyway.

Saturday, September 27, 2008

Worst YTD for the Martin Zweig Stock Screen so far

I went back and looked over AAII's data for the Zweig screen since 1998. This has been the worst year for the stock screen since AAII began tracking it. AAII tracks the stock screen on a monthly basis. Here's the breakdown:

From January through September:

1998 31%
1999 16.3%
2000 40.2%
2001 19.8%
2002 12.9%
2003 38.1%
2004 25.2%
2005 25.7%
2006 7.2%
2007 15.9%
2008 -10.5%

Friday, September 26, 2008

Week In Review 9-26-08

This was a topsy turvy week. I was very hard to grind out anything as the markets waited for the decision makers in Washington. I had a few good trades go bad as the market chopped about.

I made 5.42R for the week thanks to today's trade.

The Zweig RS 5 screen lost 5.5% this week. Zweig MACD lost 8.22%. Ouch.

Finally, I get a trade that works out the way I planned it. This trade came from a NR7 signal using Trade Ideas. I spotted it just as it was breaking out of the "bull flag" consolidation and I put a stop just below at 20.06. After leaving money on the table on several of my trades recently, I decided to place a limit order at 21.09 where I estimated that the "measured move" would end.

I went for a bike ride and returned to find the stock sold. I assumed that I had stopped out with a 1R loss but then I noticed that the limit order had triggered. The stock was on its way back down when I got home, so I was relieved to see that I had benefited by unemotionally trading my plan.

In the past I would have trailed my stops using the 20EMA (green line) as my threshold, so I probably would have sold at 20.70. Corey at Afraid to Trade (my mentor extraordinaire) challenged me to change the way I was setting my stops and determining my exits when I spoke to him last week. I owe him for the success of this trade.

Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Down another 1R

I shouldn't trade on days that I have obligations. I don't seem to take everything into account and I end up making hurried decisions. Today I took 3 trades and lost 1.10R total. Toward the end of the day I was actually up 1R but as the market rolled over I lost two thirds of the trade. Oh well.

It was pretty choppy out there today, so I guess I don't feel too bad.
LLL was a stock that I was watching throughout the day. Check out the wicks on those candles. Days like these are hard to trade.

Monday, September 22, 2008

The Stock Market for Beginners


Sometimes I can't believe the mistakes I make. This weekend I vowed to hold my positions to their target and avoid trailing stops. The two trades detailed here are obvious examples of how I broke that rule. I wanted too desperately to keep my profits and I placed my stop along the 20 EMA instead of shooting for my targets (blue arrows). For the day I lost 1.82R. Crud.


I was glad to see that the market didn't scream forward again today. I think this pull-back is healthy. I have no idea where we're headed, but it does seem like all the rules have changed. Crazy times.

Saturday, September 20, 2008

Mamaliga

When I lived in Romania, I was introduced to the country's obsession with a simple dish called Mamaliga. I tried to like it, but to me it was bland and the texture made me gag.

My friend Gabi has created a YouTube video of how to make the dish. You can see it on his blog that is dedicated to all things Mamaliga. He cracks me up.

Oh the insanity--Week in Review 9-20-08

I'm still pretty ignorant of stock market history, but from what I read from people who know, this was one unprecedented week. I'll have to admit I was feeling a little odd on Thursday and Friday. It almost felt like the end of the market as I knew it. Everything seemed to be changing, and I became worried about my future as a trader.

Friday's opening gap made it nearly impossible for me to get into any trades with good probabilities. It seemed like every stock gapped up 3-6% and then flatlined the rest of the day. There was really no wiggle room for me to trade in. That's OK, because I took the day off and got some stuff done around the house.

It's crazy that the markets ended up pretty much where they were before the week began.

The down days were good for me as I made 11.22R for the week. I'm thinking anyone with some good sense could have made a LOT of money this week.

The Zweig RS 5 screen lost .20% this week while the MACD screen (with only on candidate) made over 9%.

Trader Mike has a good post about the spikes that a lot of stocks showed during Friday's frantic trading action. I noticed strange spikes on a lot of stocks yesterday and that's part of the reason I stayed out.

Thursday, September 18, 2008

It was me

If any of you were wondering what really caused the market's unexpected surge around 2:30 today--I sold all my long ETFs in my long-term portfolio. It always works that way.

Today I lost .23R on two trades. Again, I didn't trade my plan. I had my stops way too close and I got jumpy with every move. Here are the two trades I took today.

Wednesday, September 17, 2008

Stock Market Day Trading

Here are the two trades I took today.

Wow . . . Again

That was buttock ugly. I managed to squeeze out nearly 3R on two trades. I could have made a lot more but once again I had an appointment that kept me from managing my trades. Some day I'll be able to do this without interruption.

Charles Kirk has a very well written and thought out piece about our current situation and government interference.

I was way wrong when I decided to go long in my retirement portfolio. I haven't been able to pull the trigger and dump the losers.

Tuesday, September 16, 2008

The Traveling Trader

I've seen a bit of the world, but this video that I ran across this summer inspired me.



Where is Matt Video

Does anybody out there have experience trading on the go? How do you keep things secure? Do businesses with WiFI hotspots get upset when you're streaming quotes over their bandwidth?

My goal is to start traveling with my family in the next 3 to 5 years. I'm planning to set up a "home base" in a country that is cheap to live in and friendly. I lived in Romania for two years so that seems to be a logical first base.

Monday, September 15, 2008

Wow


Despite this being the suckiest market day in quite some time, it was my best day trading so far. I managed an 8.77R gain. It could have been more, but both stocks spiked around 3:30pm and stopped me out before they continued downward. Oh well, I'll take what I can get.

Unfortunately my two highest "R" gainers for the month came on trades where I risked half of what I normally do. The first was the result of my fear of more losses, the second was today on AIV (chart above) where I only got a partial fill. I decided not to chase the stock and canceled the remaining order--crud.
I honestly thought that the market would capitulate at 3:30pm and come roaring back as the bargains were snatched up by the big players. I was pleased to get out of my trades quickly despite losing 2R in the process. Better safe than sorry.

I'm not sure where this leaves us. Is the selling finally over? I have no clue, but I think this day was healthy for the market. We didn't have any "rescuers" today, and the market was allowed to adjust on its own. It's about time.

Sunday, September 14, 2008

When I used to have hair


And bad eyesight. . .

Missed this opportunity



Here's a trade I should have taken on Friday. I'm learning that narrow 30 minute candles aren't confirmation enough for a high probability trade. BEXP showed a "bull flag" on the 5 minute chart at the same time it was painting a narrow 30 minute candle (around 11:30). If I had bought it when it broke out from the "flag" pattern and held until the end of the day, I could have had a 7R profit.

It could be nasty tomorrow

Daytrading makes news like this less scary:

US asset prices tumble
Wall Street Bankers Teeter
Lehman Heads Toward Brink
Wall Street Prepares

Tomorrow will be very interesting.

Maybe I won't have my regular Diet Mountain Dew for breakfast tomorrow.





Saturday, September 13, 2008

Week In Review 9-12-08

The week started off good for me and then I blew it. I got too cocky and started trading outside my plan. I ended up the week down .21R but it sure feels like I was down more. I could have had a very good week if it wasn't for knee-jerk trades that I shouldn't have taken.

For the month of September I'm down 2.55R.


The screens came to life this week with Zweig RS 5 making 2.43% and the Zweig MACD making 3.5% (on one stock -- COH).

Tuesday, September 9, 2008

Another Bizarre Day --And a Decent Profit

I didn't think yesterday's gains would disappear quite this fast. My trading was a mess this morning and it was all my fault. I started with the right attitude, but I jumped in way too soon and bought 4 stocks that had nothing to do with my trading plan. I even bought DELL because I heard that the CEO (Dell) bought a bunch of stock. Apparently I have learned any lessons over the FIVE YEARS OF SIMILAR MISTAKES.

I stopped out of DELL quite quickly and went long on three others. What is my deal?!!

I stopped out of them rather quickly as well. I was down 4R and felt like a complete moron.

So I dusted myself off and decided to trade like I did in August. I waited for the kinds of setups that worked and found a couple of winners. NRG was my biggest R win. It was up 8R for a bit before recovering a bit for a 5.5R gain.Overall I made 3.53R today. It should have been a lot more, but I'll take it.

I thought when I started using real cash that I'd become more disciplined. That hasn't been the case. I find myself getting out of trades too quickly when they start going against me and obsessing about taking gains too quickly when I've made some money.

I've also tried too many "hot dog" trades where I have no real confirmation, but the temptation of making quick bucks overwhelms my logic and risk management. Hopefully today will boost my confidence a bit, and I'll apply the lessons I've learned--but probably not.

Monday, September 8, 2008

Another Nutty Day

I wasn't too thrilled about taking any positions today despite everyone being thrilled about the bailout and the subsequent market gap up of over 350 points on the DOW. I was pretty sure that things wouldn't hold up all day, and they didn't. I decided to take a few positions around 11am and a few of them made a few bucks and a few lost a few. My portfolio lost about a tenth of a percent overall.

Sunday, September 7, 2008

Angry traders

My most recent post has garnered a LOT of e-mail and a few comments so far. I am surprised by the number of people who get upset at me for some of the decisions that I make about how I spend my money. My viewpoint is that it takes money to educate myself, and some of that money is going to be wasted on stuff that doesn't teach me anything (other than to avoid wasting my money like that again!!).

I've spent a lot of money on services, newsletters, trading plans, mentoring, screeners, etc., and with very few exceptions, I've learned from all of them. Trading is a discipline that's in constant flux and has billions of bits of information that are impossible for anyone to totally comprehend. That's what I enjoy about it. It's new every day and there is always something to learn.

You can't be a tightwad with your money if you want to learn how to trade. There is lots of information out there for free (including this blog), but you've got to pay for the deeper stuff that can only come from talking to people who can actually show you how to make money because they've done it.

Yeah, I made a dumb mistake buying this last bit of information. But I'm not flailing about like a chicken with my head cut off. I have the discipline to make money as a trader, and I've made a lot in the last few years.

This year has sucked, but I think I've grown more as a trader this year than the last 5 combined. I'm within a few months of actually fulfilling my goal of trading full time for a living, and I was nowhere near that just six months ago.

So be assured that I'm doing OK. I haven't gone insane, and I'm not a sucker, or "completely clueless" (most of the time). I wasted 70 bucks, but I'll be able to recover. Trading isn't easy, and I think that I'd be doing everybody a disservice if I avoided discussion about the boneheaded decisions I've made.

Saturday, September 6, 2008

A waste of money

I've been receiving daily e-mails from momentumstockpick.com for the last few years. They advertise "Powerful stock market resources and tools for day trading with our strategy. Discover momentum stocks in a snap and choose only the best every day."

I thought I'd give it a try--for $70 I could learn a few more things.

My loss is your gain. What I received was a link to a website that was basically about 4-5 pages of very basic information that is shared by every stock blog out there. The gist of the article encouraged looking at free news sites and buying cheap stocks that have news announcing new stuff. That's pretty much it. Revolutionary.


Friday, September 5, 2008

Well that just sucked

I traded like an idiot today. Down 4R. You name it, I did it--over-trade, revenge trade, breaking trading rules, not following the plan, entered the wrong order. Just stupid.

I rushed into things because I had an obligation so I wanted to get my positions established before I had to do anything else. That was my first mistake. So then I chose stocks that didn't fit with my system at all. I was buying right an left--anything that was moving down with the market.

Then the market started shifting upwards and it all came apart. I had a feeling that it might go that way after the sell-off yesterday.

I'm going to start posting my weekly and monthly "R" values instead of percentage up and down. It helps me in my analysis, and it should allow StockPunk readers to get a more "scalable" idea of how my performance has been.

My goal is 100R (or doubling my account) by next summer. I'm pretty confident I can do it if I avoid the mistakes that I made today.

Thursday, September 4, 2008

Not too shabby

My first day trading real money with the new system. It's a lot harder risking real money, but I managed to gain 1R today trading 7 stocks. I was up over 2R for a bit but decided to hold on to my short positions because the market was trending pretty strongly. It didn't work out the way I planned but that's the way it goes sometimes.

I'm pleased as punch to be able to gain 1R on a day where the market had some pretty huge losses. I used to dread days like this. I would watch pensively as my positions got decimated and I would grudgingly pick up the pieces at the end of the day. Now, I can decide whether or not I want to participate in the action and I can take positions that follow the trend of the market.

I'm finding that on trend days like this, there are often too many stocks to monitor and it becomes more of a crapshoot. I missed CME even though it was on my watchlist. It ended up with a 5R gain. My biggest gain was 1.85R today.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Tomorrow is the day-- I'm day trading stocks online

I've got everything setup and I must say I'm impressed with TradeStation. It offers a lot more than my Scottrade Elite platform did. I spent most of the day learning the system and I plan to make my first trades tomorrow. Exciting.

We had another non-committal day today. I saw several good setups and I'm starting to think that meandering days are good for my system. I have trouble on true trend days. I don't have enough history to make a judgment one way or the other, but things will be clearer in the coming months.

I bought a 22" monitor over the weekend and I've become one of those "snobbish" multi-monitor traders. I'll have to admit, having more than one screen makes things much easier. I was wishing I had a couple more today.

Tuesday, September 2, 2008

Nutty Day


My money is still in cyberspace somewhere so I was unable to trade today. That was a good thing as I was completely surprised by the reversal that happened today. We got a indication that things were going south and that the trend would end at the moving average crossover. That probably where I would have closed out any longs that I had.

With the news that Gustav wimped out and the subsequent drop in oil prices, I thought this would be a strong positive trend day. Shows you what I know.

Saturday, August 30, 2008

Month in Review August 2008



I didn't spend too much time with the market this week. I was busy moving my money from Scottrade to Tradestation (the transition is still not complete). Scottrade shut me down from virtual trading since I no longer had enough money in the account to support it, so Thursday and Friday I was unable to obtain real-time quotes.

My hope is to be up and running next week. I'm excited to begin the next step in my trading and I look forward to learning some new stuff as my account dwindles because of my mistakes.

The month of August went well for me (virtually). I managed an increase of 23.30R for the month. If I would have traded real money, that would put this month as my best ever. Of course when real money is involved, things change. September will be a far better judge of how my system performs.

The Zweig RS 5 screen continues to plummet with another 1.93% loss. The Zweig MACD screen managed to pull out a .53% gain for the week.
Buying the top 5 relative strength stocks at the beginning of the month and holding them through the end of August would have resulted in a 15.61% decline. Not good.

The stats for August:

Total R for the month 23.30
Win percentage 52.31%
Total trades 65
# of days I traded 11
Average # of trades per day 5.91
Average "R" per trading day 2.12
Expectancy for the month .35


Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Bigger must be better

I received three trading books in the mail today (I've got a lot more time now that I'm out of school). The Definitive Guide to Position Sizing is HUGE. The price was huge as well --$150. After paying 150 bucks for books about family therapy, I find it easier to plop down some cash for some books that will actually make me some money.

I'll let you know what I think about each of them after I get done. I'm currently reading Brian Shannon's Technical Analysis Using Multiple Time Frames (I have already read Martin Zwieg's book. I put it down there as a size reference.)

Monday, August 25, 2008

So much for opportunity

I guess today showed you just how much I know. I thought we might see a counter-trend rally in the next couple of days or weeks, but this isn't the best way to start one. I followed my advice and bought some S&P ETFs for my long-term portfolio. That was brilliant. Maybe I'll be proven right. Maybe.

Another thing that sucked today was my virtual trading platform with Scottrade went all wacky on me for 4 hours and I couldn't manage my pretend trades. I ended up the day with -.5R. I think I could have had a lot more if things were working. I'll log this day because I'll probably have messed up days like this when I go "live" in September.

Sunday, August 24, 2008

Opportunity

According to one of the short-term indicators I follow, now might be an OK time to go long. Matching this strategy to a long-only screen strategy has worked well for me in the past. Of course there are no guarantees, but things are starting to look interesting.

Saturday, August 23, 2008

StockPunk answers your questions!?!

Welcome to the second official StockPunk question and answer post! I went back and read the first official StockPunk question and answer post and I was surprised by how much I've changed since then. In a question about technical analysis I responded that TA wasn't "my bag".

Thanks to all of you who asked questions!! Questions about what I do force me to reevaluate and think through some of my decisions and makes me a better man--or something like that. OK, that enough, on with the show:

Why have you abandoned your Zweig stock screening strategy?

I had a few good years of trading using stock screens and they really fit in well with my lifestyle. I still think they are a great way to learn how to trade with minimum effort. They also provide a good way to invest without having to be too active in the market. I am employed full time and can't be close to a computer all the time so stock screens are perfect for me.

But as my passion for the stock market flourished, and I saw stock bloggers who were successfully trading for a living, I began to wonder if I would be able to do it myself. Even though it seemed like an obtainable dream I got a few titters and eye-rolling from family and friends. There’s quite a stigma out there that stock trading is dangerous and foolish.

I thought that I might be able to accomplish a trading lifestyle through stock screening. I felt I could consistently make 20 to 40% a year which would eventually cover all my expenses. When I got kicked in the teeth after the downturn in August 2007, I started wondering if there was a better way to limit my downside risk while still keeping my gains.

I knew that the Zweig screen outperformed marvelously over the long term, but I needed to put some reliability in my system to avoid the big drawdowns. I stumbled upon the Pitbull Investor website which specializes in mechanical investing through screening but also heavily emphasizes chart analysis. The site’s founder, Henry Ford, had just started offering personal mentoring over the phone, so I decided to invest in some trader education. My understanding of the markets and of technical analysis grew in leaps and bounds during our 6 hours of one-on-one instruction and I grew much more comfortable looking at a chart and understanding patterns in stock behavior. Henry also introduced me to the world of options, and I began to trade them as proxies for the stocks I liked.

But, the first six months of 2008 were brutal to my account. I was combining stock screening techniques with the technical analysis that I learned from Henry Ford without success. I had weeks of big gains followed by weeks of big losses. Nothing I did seemed to work, and my dreams of trading for a living were starting to look pretty silly.

Finally, in May things were finally starting to click. I clawed my way out of a 20% deficit to break even. My account was ready to take off, and I thought I was trading a system that was capable of 10% - 20% months and 100% years. My dream of trading for a living was alive and well.

Then the bottom dropped out on me again. In four days I lost nearly all of my gains for the month. I kept thinking each day that it couldn’t drop any further but it did. I was holding several options that were getting hammered and I couldn’t sell them because nobody wanted to buy them. Plus, I thought that the market “had to recover”. I ended up the month with a slight gain, but I wanted to figure out a way to trade where it didn’t matter what happened in the broader market—where I could care less whether the market was up or down.

My ongoing conversations and mentoring with Corey at Afraid to Trade also convinced me that if I was going to do this without the benefit of another job, I was going to have to increase the frequency of my trading and probably look at shorter hold times for my trades. Corey is a futures trader, and he doesn’t care at all about whether the market is up or down, he just wants to see a “trend” either way.

I went back and read some older posts that Ugly and TraderMike had written back when they first started day trading. Their journey toward day trading really seemed similar to mine and how they were trading really started making sense.

Another thing that I had read about on Uglychart.com but didn’t understand was position sizing, expectancy, and risk or “R”. Both Ugly and TraderMike used those terms to measure their success. I read Van K. Tharp’s book, Trade Your Way to Financial Freedom in 2007, but I really didn’t understand the concepts even though I tried to implement them in my stock screening. As my portfolio disintegrated during January and February of this year, I went back to the drawing board and re-read many of the books that I read in the past. I knew that there were some “gems” of wisdom in Van Tharp’s book, and with my wife’s help I began to dissect them to gain a deeper understanding. The concepts are really quite simple, and I’m a bit embarrassed to admit that they were over my head last year.

So that brings us to this summer when I decided that I needed a more dependable system that would allow me to limit my risk on a daily basis and create more frequent trading. I really think this is the best way for me to work toward trading full time. I enjoy the “clean slate” each day. Waking up with no worries about the direction of the market is extremely fulfilling. The money seems to flow much more readily.

I'm going to put all my effort into this, and if it doesn't work, no big deal. If it does work, I'm one step closer to my dreams.

What is does your trading office look like?

Here is my monitor setup.


Just kidding. I trade with a laptop at my dining room table.

What does your trading day look like?

I really don’t start anything until the market opens (9:30 am EST). I print out my watch lists before the open. I don’t make any trades until about 10:30am (market time) and I quit trading at 12:30pm (market time).

I see you scuba dive. What has been your best dive site?

Without a doubt, Fiji was the most amazing place I’ve ever scuba dived.

I’ve never seen anything like it . Incidentally, the dive master that took us diving in Fiji disappeared on a routine dive a year after we went with him—spooky.

What has been your worst day as a trader?

Back in 2006, I noticed that the highest relative strength stock in the Zweig screen always outperformed the rest of the screen (by more than 900%). So I brilliantly deduced that I could just put all of my money in that one stock and laugh all the way to the bank. I lost 9% of my portfolio in one day and decided that my strategy sucked. I was lucky that I didn’t lose more. I’ve learned a lot about risk management and position sizing since then.

Would you recommend any books on technical analysis?

I’ve tried to read books on the subject, but they cause my eyes to glaze over. It’s hard for me to look at charts that are already weeks to years old and that are printed in black and white. I have learned nearly everything about TA (and I assure you—it isn’t much) through stock blogs like the ones I list as my favorites on the side of StockPunk. I would also suggest having a mentor who understands TA take you through a few charts. It has been invaluable to me to have somebody walk me through chart patterns and TA concepts.

What did you get your Masters degree in?

I got a Masters in Human and Family Services. It’s basically a counseling/social work kind of degree. Two years ago, when I began the masters program, my goal was to stay in the counseling field. Now my goal is to trade for a living in the next few years. So I’m not sure what I’ll do with my degree right now.

My bachelors degree is in marketing which was never a good fit for me. I was completely miserable at a few marketing jobs that I had. I literally cried before I went to my first marketing job—I hated it that much. I haven’t used my marketing degree for the past 13 years, so we’ll see if I ever use my masters. If anything, I’m able to use a lot of what I learned in my current job as a counselor of teenagers.

What would be your advice to someone who is just starting out as a trader?

Don’t believe the hype. Trading is hard work. It takes a lot of time to learn. It can be financially dangerous. It probably won’t make you rich.

But if you love to do it, none of those things will matter and the money will eventually come.

Can you explain your “narrow candle” system a little better?

Many readers have asked about the “narrow candle” system that I’ve been using recently. It’s a daytrading system developed and shared by Maoxian back in early 2000. He called the posts “trading for dummies” and Ugly from Uglychart.com went on to term them “Dummy Trades”.

I first became interested when Ugly took it on as a personal trading system for himself in 2006. I was really into stock screening and mechanical investing during that time, and I considered technical analysis a sort of “voodoo” way of analyzing stocks. I preferred the “hard science” of stock screens with all their cool formulas (most of which I didn’t understand).

Ugly has a ton of examples of what the narrow candle trades are all about. Basically, I look at overall market direction first. Then I look for stocks that are trending with the overall market. I look for gaps in the direction of the overall market along with higher than average volume.

I use several watch lists to determine what stocks I plan to follow that day. I use a couple of stock screens (I just can’t give them up), along with high alpha stocks from Barchart.com. I also use real time scans from TradeIdeas.


Friday, August 22, 2008

Week In Review 8-22-08

I was at the hospital all day with a kid that I work with, and although the hospital offered internet access, I didn't feel right about streaming real time quotes using someone else's connection. When I got home at 2pm, there weren't many stocks on my watch list that I would have taken anyway. So, no big deal.

My fake account brought in 11.76R this week which makes me much more confident that I'm making the right move. To trade for a living I need around 5R to 6R per month. For August, I'm up 23.86R so far. We'll see if my success continues, but right now things are looking pretty good.

I went back and read a bunch of Ugly's posts from 2006. He made 40R during one of the first few months he started trading. He struggled for the next several months, so I need to take this success with a grain of salt. A lot will change when I start using real money.

Both Zweig screens suffered drawdowns this week. Zweig RS 5 is was down 3.26% while the Zweig MACD screen was down 1.61%.


Thursday, August 21, 2008

I'll take it

Another good day in terms of "R" value. I took 9 trades and made 3.53R. After reading Fooled by Randomness, I'm getting worried that a successful August (so far) is just the result of dumb luck.

I've already received several questions for Saturday's questions & answers post. Keep them coming!

Wednesday, August 20, 2008

StockPunk Questions and Answers This Saturday

I've been receiving a lot of questions about how I'm trading lately and since I just finished my masters degree (yay me), I now have some time to answer them. So for the next couple of days, you can send your questions to stockpunk@yahoo.com. Saturday I will attempt to answer all of the questions that I receive.

Please remember that I'm pretty much an idiot, so you might want to keep your questions simple.

What a mess

That was one sloppy market day. I scanned for stocks for three hours and came up with zilch. I made a trade on ENER just because it was the best looking chart that I saw. It didn't give me a very good setup, but I took it anyway and made a (lucky) 2R.

Here is the 5 minute chart of ENER with a couple of low-risk places that you could have entered the trade.

Tuesday, August 19, 2008

No time to trade

I guess one of the drawbacks to daytrading is you have to be around when the market is open. Today I had several unexpected things come up, so I wasn't able to comfortably make any decisions.

HOG had a good setup this morning and would have made 5R had I taken it. I didn't see any other good setups today, but I only had about 15 minutes to look.

Monday, August 18, 2008

Another good one

I decided to stick to virtual trading today. It would have been a good day to put some money to work. I made a virtual 6.2R.

Below is a dumb trade I made today losing 1R. I really had no reason to buy this stock (TITN) besides the volume surge at the open. The market was trending down and I thought that this would make a good counter-trend play. I had done well with this stock in the past and my bias directed me into a dumb trade. Notice there are no narrow candles near where I bought--just dumb.
I made over 3R shorting ENER. It was a much better play that made more sense both on the 30 minute and 5 minute charts.

Friday, August 15, 2008

Week In Review 8-15-08

This was another good week for pretend trading. I ended up making 7 times my risk on 18 "trades". Since the beginning of August, I have 48 trades under my belt with a 14.88R return (not including commissions). Expectancy so far is .31 which isn't too shabby.

I plan to return to using real money next week.

The Zweig RS 5 screen had another tough one with a 5.05% loss. The Zweig MACD screen made .79%.
I've been keeping Zweig stocks on my watch list and two of them made pretend money for me this week. MSO on Thursday had a swell setup that made 6.88R. Today AMED set up for a 3.4R day.

Wednesday, August 13, 2008

Broke Even

I was making money until the market turned around for a bit. I ended up breaking even (virtually) for the day.

Tuesday, August 12, 2008

Too busy to trade

I had too much going on today for pretend trading. AMED was on my watch list (unfortunately it is a Zweig top 5 RS stock) but I didn't put in a pretend trade on it since I figured I wouldn't have time to pretend sell it.

It would have been a good one. If you sold short after the 12:30 candle at about $65 with a stop at $65.50 held it through the close you would have risked 50 cents per share. If you held until the close you would have made $10.57 per share or 21.46R. That's a nice setup.

I didn't find too many other setups today as the market kind of meandered back and forth.

Monday, August 11, 2008

An encouraging day

Man, I wish my money wasn't pretend today. I made a "virtual" 7.8R.

Here is an example of one of my "trades". I bought at $33.75 with a stop at $33.55 which risked 20 cents per share. I sold at $35.44 which is a difference of $1.69 per share. That's a gain of 8.45 times my risk.

Since the money was pretend, I made some boneheaded trades just to get a feel for what works and what doesn't. So far, stocks that are under $10.00 have been really hard to make any money on. I find I get stopped out rather quickly.


I also practiced scaling out of my trades today, and two of them paid off well. AMZN was up 10R when I "sold" part of the position. The stock came down pretty hard after that. I pretended to sell a position in BBY as well and that would have paid off as the stock came back down.

I'm trying to find a broader indicator to let me know when to take profits. Since I'm trading in the direction of the indexes, I'm toying with the idea of selling when the trend in the index loses strength (like when the 20 period EMA is crossed).

I'm still learning, but I've been encouraged so far.

Sunday, August 10, 2008

This week with StockPunk

Despite the counter-trend rally that were seeing as of late, I still plan to pretend trade for a while longer. Let me assure you that I'm chomping at the bit to get back in, and I'm bothered that I may be missing out on some gains. But, this is the best thing for me right now.

In his latest newsletter, Van K. Tharp says "Given that everything is psychological, success in the markets is 60% discipline, 30% position sizing, and 10% system. You can have a great system that will be destroyed by mistakes created by a lack of discipline."

I need to work on the discipline aspect of my trading, so I plan to spend a while just pretending.

The Zweig screen has 20 candidates this week which is the most I've seen in some time. I take that as a good sign as the Zweig screen looks at growing companies that have good value.

It's still a tricky market out there. The indexes are still in a downtrend and there are still some scary things that the market is facing. But for the immediate future, things are looking better and it's worth a shot to go long for a bit.


Friday, August 8, 2008

Week In Review

The indexes may have done pretty well this week, but the Zweig screen got killed. It just doesn't do very well in see-saw market action like we saw all week. Equally weighted the screen lost 5.99% for the week.

The Zweig MACD did a little better coming in at +2.04% this week thanks to big gains in MSO and SUNH.

My account remains the same as I decided to have use virtual money this week. In terms of "R" value, my account came out up 5.10R. That's not bad. I'm always surprised when I run numbers at the end of the week.

I'm shooting for a 10 to 15 R gain per month, so this is a good start and I'm encouraged to continue hashing things out (especially after seeing the loss in the Zweig screen). I plan to have at least 100 virtual trades under my belt before committing to a trading program. 100 trades should give me a pretty good idea of what I can expect from my trading over time.